logo

All About Bank of NY Mellon Lawsuits

Learn what Bank of NY Mellon lawsuits are out there, and how to take action…

BNY Mellon has millions of customers in the United States. As it is with most large financial institutions, BNY Mellon has also faced plenty of lawsuits.

You might be curious about the lawsuits filed against BNY Mellon because as a customer, one or more of the lawsuits might be relevant to your own issues.

Here is what you need to know about suing BNY Mellon:

1

ARE LAWSUITS ALLOWED AGAINST BNY MELLON?

For customers of many banks, the terms of service contract limits the right to sue. For example, it’s possible your BNY Mellon contract says you can’t sue BNY Mellon in any court except small claims court.

To find out if your terms of service contract includes this clause, you should look through it for terms such as “binding arbitration” and “dispute resolution.”

If your contract has this clause, you should know that suing through small claims court can be complicated and time-consuming. We suggest considering filing for consumer arbitration as a better solution for resolving a dispute.

2

WHAT IS A CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT? CAN I FILE A CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT AGAINST BNY MELLON?

Class action lawsuits are designed to bring together a group of individuals with the same complaint. If your BNY Mellon contract does not have an arbitration clause, then you are eligible to join a class action lawsuit. However, if you see an arbitration clause in your contract, you may not be able to file a separate or join an existing class action lawsuit.

3

AS A BNY MELLON CUSTOMER, WHAT ARE MY OPTIONS FOR A LAWSUIT?

Several organizations accept complaints against companies like BNY Mellon. For instance. you can file a formal complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

If you are looking to take legal action, you have up to 3 options:

  • One option you have is to sue BNY Mellon in small claims court. If your claim qualifies for small claims court, you will be asked to attend a court hearing and pay legal fees to present your case.

  • Consumer Arbitration is the process laid out by many contracts in the place of a lawsuit. It lets you argue your case before an independent arbitrator who can force BNY Mellon to fix the problem and to compensate you. FairShake makes this process easy and convenient. (Find out how…)

  • If your BNY Mellon contract allows class action lawsuits, then you’ll want to find a lawyer who is suing the bank, or is planning to sue the bank.

4

TOP 5 BNY MELLON LAWSUITS:

The Bank of New York Mellon Lawsuit over Foreign Exchange Rates

The Bank of New York Mellon faced a number of foreign currency exchange rate lawsuits over the past decade. This case, which was reported by Bloomberg Law last year, reflects one instance where the bank overcharged retirement plans that invested in foreign securities.

Bank of New York Mellon will pay $12.5 million to settle a proposed class action accusing it of charging retirement plans excessive, unauthorized, and undisclosed amounts through the bank’s foreign exchange transactions.

The deal, announced in court papers filed Dec. 14, would end a novel lawsuit attempting to hold the bank liable under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act for allegedly overcharging retirement plans that invest in foreign securities. Investors accused BNY of purposefully giving them unfavorable exchange rates when buying foreign securities with their retirement plan assets, which allegedly allowed the bank to take an undisclosed cut from these transactions.

A federal judge declined to dismiss the case in 2017, saying the dividends and other amounts received by BNY in connection with these foreign currency transactions are ERISA plan assets that could cause the bank to become a fiduciary under the statute. Judge J. Paul Oetken of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York called this a “question of first impression.”

The settlement class includes trustees and fiduciaries of thousands of retirement plans covering “many thousands” of individual investors, the parties said. It comes nearly four years after BNY agreed to pay $84 million to settle claims involving foreign currency transactions brought by the Labor Department and the New York Attorney General.

The Bank of New York Mellon Lawsuit over Mismanaged Investments

This 2019 Reuters story tells us of a Bank of New York Mellon lawsuit involving mismanaged investments in mutual funds that were destined to fail.

A federal judge in Pittsburgh has rejected a bid by a Bank of New York Mellon unit to dismiss a proposed class action accusing it of imprudently investing thousands of trusts’ assets in poorly performing mutual funds managed by an affiliate.

BNY Mellon had argued that the plaintiffs, beneficiaries of the trusts, made only vague assertions that the mutual funds “underperformed” without establishing that they were an imprudent investment. In a decision on Friday, however, U.S. District Judge Nora Fischer adopted a magistrate judge’s conclusion in April that plaintiffs’ allegations were adequate to survive a motion to dismiss.

The Bank of New York Mellon Lawsuit over Unjust Mortgage Loans

The Bank of New York Mellon has made shady investments that are bad for its investors for a long time, as is apparent by this 2012 lawsuit summary by CFLA (via Reuters). This case involves risky mortgage loans the bank allegedly should not have pursued.

A federal judge rejected Bank of New York Mellon Corp’s bid to dismiss a lawsuit by investors over its role as trustee for mortgage-backed securities that led to an $8.5 billion settlement by Bank of America Corp.

U.S. District Judge William Pauley in Manhattan said on Tuesday that bondholders who invested in 26 trusts alleged to have contained risky mortgage loans from the former Countrywide Financial Corp may pursue claims against Bank of New York Mellon. He dismissed a variety of other claims.

The decision relates to a lawsuit challenging Bank of New York Mellon’s performance of its day-to-day obligations as a trustee, which includes ensuring that underlying home loans are properly documented and that bondholders’ rights are protected.

Beth Kaswan, a lawyer for four pension funds in Chicago, Michigan and Pennsylvania that brought the case, said the decision leaves intact claims over securities backed by more than $30 billion of loans, and which have suffered more than $9 billion of losses or delinquencies.

The Bank of New York Mellon Lawsuit for Whistleblower’s Unlawful Termination

CityWire brings us this story of a 2018 lawsuit from an ex-Bank of New York Mellon employee who was ousted from the bank after raising concern about suspicious client activity.

BNY Mellon is being sued for unlawful termination by a former employee who claims he was fired for raising concerns over a corporate Panamanian client he suspected to be engaged with money laundering and public corruption.

Charles Austin, a former vice president and senior relationship manager within BNY’s corporate trust division, says that he was pushed out of the bank after he recommended it end a relationship with Panamanian financial services firm Global Bank after a ‘weeks-long’ investigation in April 2017. 

[…]

In addition to filing a wrongful termination suit, Austin claims that BNY violated the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, which protects corporate whistleblowers, as he alleges he was fired after reporting his conclusions about the Global Bank and calling into BNY Mellon’s ethics hotline to report ‘adverse treatment’ by his colleagues. 

The Bank of New York Mellon Lawsuit on Social Media Racial Discrimination

The Bank of New York Mellon is also no stranger to employee lawsuits. In this TribLive lawsuit summary from 2020, an ex-bank employee claims she was fired for her posting about a car driven to a protest.

A former employee claims in a lawsuit that BNY Mellon fired her after she made a social media comment referencing a group protesting the police shooting of unarmed teen Antwon Rose , court records show.

The lawsuit filed in federal court alleges that Lisa Ellis, a Mt. Lebanon resident and senior analyst at the company’s wealth management department in Pittsburgh, was fired because she is white. It accuses BNY Mellon officials of violating employment discrimination and civil rights laws by firing her “without notice and without conducting an investigation” on July 3, three days after she made a Facebook post flagged as controversial.

[…]

The lawsuit further alleges that activists worked with a BNY Mellon human resources official to solicit people to complain about Ellis and build a case to have her terminated, with some activists reportedly boasting about their ability to get white people fired, Colianni said.

According to the lawsuit, BNY Mellon provided “conflicting reasons” for firing Ellis, first referring to their code of conduct and later, when Ellis filed for unemployment benefits, saying she was fired for “poor job performance” — an assessment she claims contradicts prior positive performance reviews during her three-year tenure with the company.

What's your complaint?


Best of the Best. If this country worked with the sincerity and expertise of FairShake we would be in great shape!

Stocksy_txpd2fb379aCMc200_Medium_1013152 Allie, real FairShake customer

They got more done in a few weeks than I did in over two years.

jonas-kakaroto-KIPqvvTOC1s-unsplash John, real FairShake customer

I can’t say enough good about this company! They are really a light for us in a very hard time.

Mark Mark, real FairShake customer

Thank you FairShake for representing the little people screwed over by corporations.

Stocksy_txpd2fb379aCMc200_Medium_1016567 Amanda, real FairShake customer

I was having problems with the company for months. That you could make it resolved in a few days is wonderful.

eye-for-ebony-nOHn3pIyPaw-unsplash Marisol, real FairShake customer

It's not right what Big Business can get away with if we let them. People need to know someone is out there to help!

Stocksy_txpd2fb379aCMc200_Medium_670432 Virgil, real FairShake customer

FairShake helps put the power and money back in your hands

Take Action